Bennett says the matter “has already been settled under Alabama law”
Albert Turner Jr. asked the Perry County Circuit Court on Friday, Nov. 13, to declare him the winner of the District 1 seat on the Perry County Commission and to remove Donald J. Bennett Sr. from the office.
The complaint, stamped filed that day by the circuit clerk’s office, is an election contest and, in the alternative, a petition for a writ of quo warranto, the action used to test a person’s right to hold a public office. It is brought in Turner’s name and in the name of the State of Alabama on his relation, and names Bennett as the defendant.
Circuit Judge R. Bryan Jones, who drew the case by random assignment, recused himself Sunday, Nov. 15. His order, entered on the court’s own motion, cites Canon 3(C)(1) of the Alabama Canons of Judicial Ethics, under which a judge should step aside when the law requires it or when his impartiality might reasonably be questioned.
Gov. Kay Ivey appointed Jones, of Selma, to the 4th Judicial Circuit bench in February. He had been an assistant district attorney for the circuit.
A deputy served the summons and complaint Monday, Nov. 16, according to the return filed with the circuit clerk that day. The summons gives Bennett 30 days from service to file an answer.
The county canvassing board canvassed the returns of the Nov. 3 general election on Tuesday, Nov. 10, and certified the results before the complaint was filed. Bennett was sworn in Nov. 11. The complaint says the board “has not yet certified Bennett as the duly elected Perry County Commissioner for District 1.”
Election night returns gave Bennett 590 votes to 560 write-in votes. His was the only name printed on the District 1 ballot, and Turner, who had held the seat since 2000, ran as a write-in candidate.
The complaint says the votes cast for Bennett were illegal and that Turner received a majority of the legal votes.
It rests on the Aug. 21 decision of the State Democratic Executive Committee in Turner’s appeal of the May 19 primary. According to the complaint, the state committee directed Probate Judge Carlton L. Hogue, as chairman of the Perry County Democratic Executive Committee, to amend the certification of Bennett as the party’s nominee and to certify Turner, and the decision was communicated to Hogue that day by state party chairman Sen. Bobby Singleton and by Ben Harris.
The complaint says Hogue instead certified Bennett to himself as probate judge, without convening the county committee, and submitted Bennett’s name for the ballot.
It cites a section of state election law that says a candidate disqualified by a political party after the ballot is set remains on the ballot and that the canvassing board “shall not certify any votes for the candidate.”
As grounds for the contest, the complaint lists malconduct by Hogue as county party chairman, malconduct by Hogue as probate judge, illegal votes, and that a recount of the legal votes would name Turner the winner. It says the county canvassing board reported no machine votes for Turner but “acknowledged a significant number of write-in votes most if not all of which were write-in votes cast for Turner.”
The second count asks for a judgment that Bennett be ousted from the office and that Turner is entitled to hold it. The complaint says Turner has deposited $4,000 with the clerk as security for costs.
Turner signed the complaint and swore to it before a notary. No attorney’s name appears on it or on the summons.
Bennett answered in a statement posted Friday night.
“I respect the right of any citizen to go to court, and I’m confident the court will see that this matter has already been settled under Alabama law,” he wrote.
Bennett wrote that he was certified as the winner of the primary, that the state committee’s ruling was given verbally and that no written judgment or order was ever sent to the county Democratic chairman or to him.
“Judge Hogue did not act on his own,” Bennett wrote. He wrote that Turner sued Hogue to stop the certification and that Montgomery County Circuit Judge Monet Gaines dismissed the suit because the deadline for changing the ballot had passed. Gaines dismissed that suit Sept. 1.
Bennett wrote that he received 590 votes on Nov. 3 and 10 provisional votes on Nov. 10, for a total of 600. In a post Friday afternoon on his Facebook page, Turner said he received more than 570 write-in votes.
In the same post, Turner said his campaign had taken claims of machine tampering, forgery, mail fraud and mail tampering to the 4th Judicial Circuit district attorney’s office, and that the office had referred them to the state attorney general’s office and the FBI. The complaint filed Friday does not raise those claims.
Bennett led Turner 398 to 397 in the primary after provisional ballots were counted. A July 9 recount ended 398 to 398, and Hogue broke the tie for Bennett. The state party’s contest committee voted 5-0 on Aug. 21 to count a disputed ballot for Turner, putting him ahead 399 to 398.
Bennett wrote that his attention remains on “roads, jobs, the airport, economic development and the families of Perry County,” and he asked the people of District 1 “to stay patient, stay respectful and let the courts do their work.” Bennett answered the roll for District 1 at the commission’s organizational meeting Nov. 11. The commission’s next regular meeting is at 6 p.m. Tuesday, Nov. 24, at the Albert Turner Sr. Courthouse Annex.